Event Calendar
May 2012
(view month)
S M T W R F S
* * 01 02 03 04 05
06 07 08 09 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17 18 19
20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 * *
<< (add event) >>


User Blox 4
- Put stuff here

Barack Obama
"Lincoln Sells Out Slaves"
by: Rob Kailey - Sep 13
1 Comments
If You Haven't Seen This
by: Rob Kailey - Apr 28
5 Comments
Impeach the President?
by: Rob Kailey - Mar 16
15 Comments
It's the system, stupid!
by: Jay Stevens - Oct 25
7 Comments

Search




Advanced Search


Rob Kailey is a working schmuck with no ties or affiliations to any governmental or political organizations, save those of sympathy.

The Ten Most Influential Montanans of 2010

by: Doug Coffin

Sun Dec 26, 2010 at 11:39:15 AM MST


OK. We talked about the ten most influential people of the 21st century. Let's try for the ten most influential Montanans of the last year (or 2 or 3). Here's my list:
1. Brian Schweitzer
2. Will Descamps
3. Max Baucus
4. John Tester
5. Waded Cruzado
6. Denis Rheberg
7. Donald Molloy
8. George Dennison
9. Bob Lake
10. Canis Lupus

Looking at this or any list you have to understand the huge impact of government in our lives and on the Montana economy.

#1 It makes sense that the Gov tops our list. His impact is felt on all the major aspects of our life and work: the state budget, K-12 education and higher education, tourism, agriculture, etc. Schweitzer named a new Regent and two new University Presidents were hired. Make no mistake about it, the Gov has a huge say in who they are a big say in what state govt money goes where.

#2. Will Descamps is the State Republican Party leader. In a year when they had a huge landslide at the polls, he has to get a lot of the credit. Much of that comes from recruiting candidates well before the election. Admittedly it was a national trend that rolled over Montana, but the state GOP was poised to take advantage and it did in a big way. We'll feel the influence of the 2011-13 legislature for a long time.

#3. Max is one of the most powerful Senators in Washington and that is always felt at home. If the Gov controls the flow of state money in MT, Max controls the flow of the federal money in MT and MT gets a lot relative to other states. He has a big say in nominees for federal jobs in Montana (US Marshall, etc.) and his impact on Montanans through PPACA (Obamacare) and ARRA (The Stimulus) was huge. The big question buzzing around is:Will we see Schweitzer vs Baucus in 2014? I bet not.

#4. Jon Tester is all over LiTW and the Newspapers over his Wilderness Bill that, of course, met the same fate as wilderness bills over the last thirty years. I know there was stink over his DREAM vote, but beyond most of us liberals, nobody in MT gives a damn about that. Look for a Rheberg-Tester matchup for 2012.

#5. Waded Cruzado is the new President of Montana State University. She has hit the ground running and, since Montana University System campuses are economic engines for most major population centers in the state she has a big impact. Cruzado's energy is palpable. She has already begun a major reorganization of the MSU branch of the university system. Look for much more before she leaves for greener pastures.

#6. How could we not include Denny? He also gets some credit for leading the GOP sweep in MT and for stirring up the "Great Wolf Debate" (which really isn't great at all). Denny also has some impact in WDC, but not much. He's most infamous for being one of the least effective legislators under the dome, except when it comes to building his personal fortune though is position. He still manages to win by a landslide. Go figger.

#7. Donald Molloy, as our Federal District judge has a huge impact with rulings on Canis Lupus and other key MT economic and environmental issues. He also made the headlines by moving to senior status. Of course Max will have a big say on who Obama names to replace him.

#8. George Dennison retired after a very influential career and essentially picked his own replacement. The infamous $65K "search that never was" made national headlines. His impact on the other side of the U-system (UM vs MSU or Griz-Cat) has been big and his exit was no exception. What will come from the new Prez (Engstrom)? Two months isn't enough time to tell.

#9. Bob Lake? You might ask.... yes, because the state senator, owned by the real estate industry, was the behind the scenes operator who engineered and shepherded CI-105 through the electoral process. It stands as a hallmark to special interest politics and it's one of the biggest ruses that has ever been pulled over the eyes of Montana voters. The cynical notion of using millions in out of state funding to eliminate a tax that doesn't exist most certainly sets a precedent to be followed in the future.      

#10. Canis lupus, the grey wolf, has been illegitimately splattered all over our state newspapers and blogs. If there has ever been a bigger non-issue, I don't know what it is. But three of my top 10 influencers are there because or the great grey-boy. So who am I to talk?
Truth be told the grey wolf has little influence on our economy or lifestyle, except to pull in a few more tourists, sell some more pictures and provide government work to some micro-managing wildlife mangers in MT, ID and WY. Grey-boy also serves to get Do-Nothing-Denny reelected.

So there you have my top ten....who shows up on your list?  
 

Doug Coffin :: The Ten Most Influential Montanans of 2010
Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Bookmark and Share
Print Friendly View Send As Email

Time to move outside the political arena (4.00 / 1)
to find the most influential. And it's not always "influence" that is most important to a person's contributions to Montana.

So here's some people missing from your list:

1) Elouise Cobell, for persevering in her lawsuit against the U.S. Government for the misuse of Trust Funds over generations. The decade long lawsuit was finally settled, and the $3.2 billion compensation was authorized by Obama a few weeks ago.

2) Greg Mortenson, founder of the Central Asia Institute  and author of "Three Cups of Tea," which is mandatory reading for the military fighting in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Mortenson is responsible for building many schools in Afghanistan and Pakistan, and raising an awareness of cultural and educational issues in those countries.

3) Steve Running, Nobel Peace Prize-winning professor from the U of M. One of the world's leading scientists in the field of global ecosystem monitoring.

4) Linda Pritzker, Hyatt family heiress and philanthropist; one of the top 4 or 5 richest MOntanans. Lives quietly in W. Montana and is involved in many different causes. Is helping to bring the Dali Lama to Montana for the blessing of the Ewam in the Jocko Valley in either 2011 or 2012.

5) Jeff Ament, Pearl Jam bassist. Involved in many philanthropic endeavors in MOntana, as well as inspiring a generation of youth with his music.

6) A quartet of artists from Bozeman who influenced generations of visual arts in Montana for over 60 years: Bob & Gennie DeWeese, Frances Senska and Peter Voulkos. All of whom's legacy lives on in the arts in Montana today, and their work and teaching influenced 10's of thousands of Montanans, and teachers currently working all over the state.

Animal influence? The American Bison, without a doubt. Leading the fight between the old west and the new west. The wolf may be hated for its predatory ways. But the bison is hated because it eats grass--grass that the old west bastions believe belongs to cows. The buffalo will lead the way in a transformative landscape in the 21st century in Montana, one that is more in tune with values less absorbed with exploitation, and more focused on restoration.

The land? Wilderness. Wilderness and wild country influences all Montanans who choose to wander  within or near their pristine boundaries. A journey through a wilderness can change a person's outlook on life in many, many unquantifiable ways.


Time to move outside the political arena (0.00 / 0)
to find the most influential. And it's not always "influence" that is most important to a person's contributions to Montana.

So here's some people missing from your list:

1) Elouise Cobell, for persevering in her lawsuit against the U.S. Government for the misuse of Trust Funds over generations. The decade long lawsuit was finally settled, and the $3.2 billion compensation was authorized by Obama a few weeks ago.

2) Greg Mortenson, founder of the Central Asia Institute  and author of "Three Cups of Tea," which is mandatory reading for the military fighting in Afghanistan and Pakistan. Mortenson is responsible for building many schools in Afghanistan and Pakistan, and raising an awareness of cultural and educational issues in those countries.

3) Steve Running, Nobel Peace Prize-winning professor from the U of M. One of the world's leading scientists in the field of global ecosystem monitoring.

4) Linda Pritzker, Hyatt family heiress and philanthropist; one of the top 4 or 5 richest MOntanans. Lives quietly in W. Montana and is involved in many different causes. Is helping to bring the Dali Lama to Montana for the blessing of the Ewam in the Jocko Valley in either 2011 or 2012.

5) Jeff Ament, Pearl Jam bassist. Involved in many philanthropic endeavors in MOntana, as well as inspiring a generation of youth with his music.

6) A quartet of artists from Bozeman who influenced generations of visual arts in Montana for over 60 years: Bob & Gennie DeWeese, Frances Senska and Peter Voulkos. All of whom's legacy lives on in the arts in Montana today, and their work and teaching influenced 10's of thousands of Montanans, and teachers currently working all over the state.

Animal influence? The American Bison, without a doubt. Leading the fight between the old west and the new west. The wolf may be hated for its predatory ways. But the bison is hated because it eats grass--grass that the old west bastions believe belongs to cows. The buffalo will lead the way in a transformative landscape in the 21st century in Montana, one that is more in tune with values less absorbed with exploitation, and more focused on restoration.

The land? Wilderness. Wilderness and wild country influences all Montanans who choose to wander  within or near their pristine boundaries. A journey through a wilderness can change a person's outlook on life in many, many unquantifiable ways.


I like it JC, Elouise Cobell is most certainly there (0.00 / 0)
I would most certainly agree with including Cobell, and probably Mortenson. Truthfully I hadn't heard of Linda Prtizker. Likewise, Steve has had a big impact on our curriculum, no doubt. I like smoking some folks out with input. It's very informing.

Doug Coffin

[ Parent ]
In truth (0.00 / 0)
If you exchange "influence" for "contribution", you do fundamentally change the nature of the examination.  You are welcome to call me a cynic (I do) but contribution puts a positive spin that influence doesn't allow.  For instance, though Greg Mortenson is huge in his contribution to the world and thereby Montana, his actual influence in Montana is very small, more's the pity.  Conversely, Greg Gianforte is hugely influential in Montana, and few even know who he is (Founder, CEO, chief stockholder and President of Right Now Technologies.)  I expect they will when Daines completes his run for Senate, regardless of outcome.

Then there are folks like Aaron Flint, and Roger Koopman.  Flint is no doubts more influential than the Lie Monkey based on a larger platform, but they are both driving a particular narrative in Montana which has born awful fruit.  Contribute? Hell no.  But definitely influential.

Then there is Gary Marbut.  I won't launch a screed right now, but one might want to consider the unhealthy influence he has had on the last legislative session, the election of 2010, and the bills upcoming from his support and supporters.

For animal, I would say it's a toss up between wolves and elk, with elk taking the nod.  Elk drive policy, economy and controversy.  It is elk that are spreading brucellosis and next to no one wants to deal with that because elk are the holy grail of Montana outdoor industry.  Elk have been the focus of much of the controversy concerning wolves.  Take away wolves, and few would care.  Take away bison and even less would (do) care.  Take away elk ...  that's influence.

And for land space, I would yet again disagree.  The National Parks have had record seasons of attendance.  Yellowstone, not much of a surprise there. But Glacier?  


[ Parent ]
Let's just say (0.00 / 0)
that I don't want to measure "influence" by how much headline space, or air time and individual politician or movement gets. For instance, Mortenson's book has been read by a lot of Montanans (it's next up on my reading list, though I've had lots of discussion with folks about it), and influences what they think about the AfPak war in particular, and culture in general. But you'll never get that quantified as "influential" by the media.

But I'm most interested, in what I wrote, is to get away from the final week of the year's focus on politics as being the most "influential" stories of the year. This sort of media sensationalism just plays into a meme that i am coming to abhor. The 24 hour news cycle dominated by politics really has created an illusion of what is really important in our lives, individually and collectively.

I merely looked within to see what sorts of things were influencing my life to a large degree in the past year, and wrote about them. I found that politics and government doings had next to no influence on my life.  I consulted on a documentary about bison. My year was focused on art and music--bringing performance back into it. Culture. See the new BFC buffalo calendar (you might have it on your shelves at the bookstore)? I produced that. I published a book for a friend. I'm working on marketing a DVD compendium and website for a yogi. And much more of this sort of stuff.  My art school training at MSU was instrumental in getting and accomplishing much of my work.

I see the Yum Chenmo statue surrounded by the still-under-construction 8-spoked Dharma Wheel taking shape a mile away across the pastures. I'm within the security perimeter they will establish when the Dali Lama show up to bless it in the near future. I've met a wonderful group of people associated with this endeavor, all of them living outside the normal political spheres. I live on the reservation, and folks are excited about the Cobell suit coming to fruition. My daughter has brought more influence into my life than has the president. My livelihood has been influenced much more by the activities of my community and friends than it has by any legislation passed or panned by Congress, or act of the SCOTUS.

Politics has become a distraction from what is real in my life. Politicians are artifices hiding behind a huge mask. The lesson of Obama--that he was a blank slate where people could project their aspirations and their fears--taught me much of the value of politics and how it is manipulated by the media to sell print, air time, and click-throughs.  So I choose to spend the end of the year ignoring all of the political highlights, and instead look within to find what has stirred my passions in the year past. And I find that what is real in my life is not embodied in the normal top 10 lists.

And elk? Sure, they're a big story. But I totally disagree that they drive policy, economy and controversy more than bison. Actually, the bison ranching industry is bigger than the elk hunting industry, by far. And Yellowstone and Glacier? They are both dominated by their wilderness landscapes. Like 90%+ of their land base is wilderness. I don't refer to the value of wilderness depending on its land designation, or managing agency or corporation. Glacier and Yellowstone would not be what they are without their wilderness underpinnings. Wilderness is the backdrop against which people view and photograph places like Going-to-the-Sun, Old Faithful, Grand Canyon of the Yellowstone, Many Glacier...


[ Parent ]
Great List (0.00 / 0)
I like the addition of Cobell.  Waded Cruzado is also a great choice.  She is definitely the most influential education official in the state, and I think we'll continue to see great things from her.  I would put Jon Tester above Will Deschamps however.  

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?


Bookmark and Share

Poll
Voting. Useful or not?
Yes!
No!
Maybe, but only if you vote my way.
There are theories that ...
Meh ...

Results

Blog Roll
  • A Secular Franciscan Life
  • Big Sky Blog
  • David Crisp's Billings Blog
  • Discovering Urbanism
  • Ecorover
  • Great Falls Firefly
  • Intelligent Discontent
  • Intermountain Energy
  • Lesley's Podcast
  • Livingston, I Presume
  • Great Falls Firefly
  • Montana Cowgirl
  • Montana Main St.
  • Montana Maven
  • Montana With kids
  • Patia Stephens
  • Prairie Mary
  • Speedkill
  • Sporky
  • The Alberton Papers
  • The Fighting Liberal
  • The Montana Capitol Blog
  • The Montana Misanthrope
  • Thoughts From the Middle of Nowhere
  • Treasure State Judaism
  • Writing and the West
  • Wrong Dog's Life Chest
  • Wulfgar!

  • Powered by: SoapBlox